Best Potato Salad Recipe - Guess my secret ingredient! +HOW-TO VIDEO (2024)

The best potato salad recipe! This is our favorite potato salad with eggs, celery, onion, pickle relish and a creamy dressing.

Click here to SAVE this potato salad recipe!

Are you on the search for the best potato salad recipe? Potato salad is one of my favorite picnic foods, especially for spring and summer holidays like Memorial Day and 4th of July. Serve me a good potato salad and I will eat seconds and thirds. I've researched and tested a few methods for making a classic potato salad recipe and this is best of the best!

Best Potato Salad Recipe

Every picnic and potluck needs potato salad, and I'm hugely disappointed if it's missing from the table. Many times I end up making it just so I know it will be part of the spread, and this recipe is hard to beat!

Ingredient List

(full printable recipe at end of this post)

We use gold potatoes with a delicious creamy mayonnaise and mustard dressing. Below are the rest of the ingredients you need to make this classic potato salad recipe.

Here's what you need:

• Gold potatoes (2 lb)
• Eggs (4 large boiled)
• Sweet onion (half)
• Celery (2 stalks)
• Dill pickle (2 spears)
• Mayonnaise (1 cup)
• Mustard (2 teaspoons)
• Apple cider vinegar (2 tablespoons)
• Celery seed (find in spice aisle)
• Salt & pepper

If you want to make the salad pretty in the bowl, grab some fresh dill and paprika for garnish. Totally optional.

Click here for full recipe ingredients and instructions.

Similar Kitchen Scale

Ingredient Substitutions

I love the recipe as written, but you can definitely make changes how you see fit for your own taste buds. Consider the following variations.

• Onion - I like sweet onions, but you can definitely use green onions or red onions instead.
• Vinegar - My heart belongs to cider vinegar, but red wine vinegar and white vinegar works, too!
• Mustard - For potato salad, yellow mustard is the classic American choice and lends to a prettier color, but if you are set on using Dijon mustard, go for it!
• Pickles - I prefer dill pickles, but you can use sweet. Some recipes call for relish, and you can use it here, but I like the crunch from the pickles.
• Mayonnaise - Some swear by mayo, others prefer Miracle Whip. I'm a mayo girl but you can definitely use Miracle Whip!

How to Make Potato Salad With Egg

There is a little bit of prep to making potato salad from scratch, like chopping ingredients and boiling potatoes, but even so this comes together very simply. I recommend preparing boiled eggs a day ahead so they are ready to be peeled and chopped. Maybe even go ahead and chop the celery, onions and pickles while the eggs are boiling so they're ready the day you make the potato salad, too!

Steps to make potato salad:

1. Boil potatoes in large pot of water.
2. Peel and cube potatoes.
3. Mix warm potatoes with vinegar with salt and pepper.
4. Chill 20 minutes.
5. Combine mayonnaise, mustard, celery seed.
6. Stir in celery, onions and pickles.
7. Fold in potatoes and eggs.
8. Serve immediately or chill several hours.

Click here for the full recipe ingredients and instructions.

Another time saver is to complete some of the steps while waiting for the potatoes to boil. Peel and chop the eggs at this time, and the other ingredients if you didn't previously.

Your Questions Answered

What kind of potatoes are best for potato salad?
The best potatoes are Yukon golds. Some will tell you red potatoes are best because they hold their shape better, but I like a little bit of "mash" in my potato salad. Do not use Russet potatoes unless that's your only choice, as they will be too mushy texture. New or baby potatoes don't do well in this recipe, either.

Should I boil potatoes whole or cut them up before boiling?
No. Do not peel or cut your potatoes before boiling or you may end up with waterlogged potatoes. You do not want watery potato salad, which is why I keep my potatoes sealed in their skins while boiling then peel and cut them after they've cooled a few minutes. The peel easily removes with just your fingers.

Marquette Castings Dutch Oven | Similar Kitchen Scale

How far in advance can I make potato salad?
This is best when it is made at least one day before -- and even better on day two! You can serve this potato salad right away, but I recommend allowing it to chill several hours first. It will last in the fridge for up to 1 week, but it tastes so good I doubt it'll last that long!

Tips for Making the Best Potato Salad

• Add vinegar mixture while potatoes are still warm. Instead of mixing the vinegar with the mayo dressing, I like to add the vinegar mixture to the potatoes while they are still warm and let it chill 20 minutes to enhance the zing. It's a noticeable difference that is worth the extra minor step.
• Rinse your knife periodically with warm water while cutting the boiled potatoes. This will reduce the amount of starch and be easier to continue cutting with less mashed taters.
• Let potatoes cool before adding the dressing. If you add the mayonnaise dressing to the potatoes while they are still warm, the mayo will become liquidy. This is yet another reason to not skip the 20 minute chilling step mentioned above!
• Make ahead. You can eat the potato salad right away, but the flavor is best the next day.

More Picnic Salad Recipes

If you love this classic potato salad then you should check out these other salad recipes!

• Classic Macaroni Salad
• Fruit Salad
• Broccoli Salad
• Grape Salad
• Greek Pasta Salad

Print this recipe or PIN it to save for later. Made this recipe? Leave a star rating and tag me on social media @seededtable so I can see. I love hearing from you!

This recipe was originally published May 2020 and updated with optimized photos in March 2021.

Recipe Card